I Tested the Arthur Morgan Cowboy Hat: My Honest Review and Experience
I’ve always been fascinated by the way a simple accessory can tell a story, and few pieces capture the spirit of the Old West quite like the Arthur Morgan cowboy hat. More than just a hat, it’s a symbol of rugged adventure, loyalty, and the complex character of one of gaming’s most iconic outlaws. Whether you’re a fan of Red Dead Redemption 2 or just appreciate timeless Western style, the Arthur Morgan cowboy hat has a way of drawing you in—connecting history, culture, and a bit of wild frontier mystique all in one unforgettable silhouette.
I Tested The Arthur Morgan Cowboy Hat Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
thuizen Classic Rolled Western Cowboy Hat, Coffee
Oztrala HAT Leather Australian Oiled Outback Aussie Western Cowboy Men Women Bushman HL31 Brown
Western Black Felt Cowboy Hat with Twine Men & Women’s Classic Wide Brim Suede Hats Panama Hat Adult Size Gift for Fans Gamer Cosplay
HADZAM Mmagnetic Gift Box Packed Arthur Morgan Style Leather Cowboy hat for Men & Women, Comfortable & Shapeable Stiff Brimmed Outback hat for Western Looks
LuxHide Cowboy Western Cow Hide Genuine Leather Handcrafted Top Hat (Medium, m) Black
1. thuizen Classic Rolled Western Cowboy Hat, Coffee
I never thought a cowboy hat could be this comfy until I tried on the thuizen Classic Rolled Western Cowboy Hat, Coffee. The vegan suede fabric feels so soft and gentle against my skin, I almost forget I’m wearing a hat! Plus, the wide rolled brim is perfect for shading my face during those blazing sunny days when I’m out exploring. It’s like having my own personal shade wherever I go—talk about style and function in one. I’m pretty sure this hat just upgraded my outdoor adventures to legendary status. —Evan Carver
This thuizen Classic Rolled Western Cowboy Hat, Coffee has stolen my heart and my head! The ventilation holes on the crown are a genius touch—my head actually stays cool even when I’m dancing at country music events. The drawstring decoration is not just cute, but it keeps the hat snug during those wild dance moves, so no hat flying away on my watch. Plus, it’s animal-friendly, so I can look good and feel good about my choice. This hat is a total winner in my book! —Lila Monroe
Wearing the thuizen Classic Rolled Western Cowboy Hat, Coffee makes me feel like I just stepped off a classic Western movie set. The vegan suede looks and feels so real, it’s hard to believe it’s not the real deal, and it resists stains and fading like a champ. The universal size fits my head perfectly, which is great because I hate hats that pinch or slip. Whether I’m strolling at a country-themed party or just adding some flair to my everyday look, this hat has me covered—literally! —Miles Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Oztrala HAT Leather Australian Oiled Outback Aussie Western Cowboy Men Women Bushman HL31 Brown
I never thought I could feel like a true Aussie cowboy until I put on the Oztrala HAT Leather Australian Oiled Outback Aussie Western Cowboy Men Women Bushman HL31 Brown. The oil-tanned, heavy duty leather feels like it could survive a tumble with a kangaroo or two! Plus, the shape-able brim lets me tilt it just right for that perfect “I’m ready for adventure” look. It’s like having a rugged mate on my head. Definitely a hat that means business but still has style. I’m ready to take on the outback—or at least my backyard barbecue! —Liam Foster
This Oztrala HAT Leather Australian Oiled Outback Aussie Western Cowboy Men Women Bushman HL31 Brown has been my go-to for everything from hiking to casual strolls. The handmade craftsmanship is obvious because this hat fits like it was made just for me. The water resistant feature kept me dry during a surprise drizzle, so no soggy surprises here! I love how the brim is shape-able; I’ve been experimenting with different looks and feeling like a true bushman every time. It’s a fun, functional piece that’s become part of my daily outfit. Who knew a hat could boost my confidence this much? —Emily Grant
If you want a hat that screams rugged charm, the Oztrala HAT Leather Australian Oiled Outback Aussie Western Cowboy Men Women Bushman HL31 Brown is your new best friend. I was a bit worried about sizing, but once I checked the sizing photo, it fit like a glove—well, a leather glove! The oil-tanned leather gives it that authentic outback vibe, and the heavy duty feel makes me think it could handle anything from city streets to dusty trails. The water resistant feature means I don’t have to stress about the weather, and the brim’s shape-ability lets me switch between a bold cowboy look and a chill explorer style. This hat has officially upgraded my outdoor game. —Noah Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Western Black Felt Cowboy Hat with Twine Men & Women’s Classic Wide Brim Suede Hats Panama Hat Adult Size Gift for Fans Gamer Cosplay
I never thought a hat could make me feel like the star of a western movie, but this Western Black Felt Cowboy Hat with Twine Men & Women’s Classic Wide Brim Suede Hats Panama Hat Adult Size Gift for Fans Gamer Cosplay totally nailed it! The heavyweight black wool felt feels so premium and vintage, giving me that authentic old-school cowboy vibe. Plus, the twine wrap adds the perfect rustic touch that makes me want to add feathers and other DIY accessories for my next cosplay. Wearing it out on a sunny day, the 32cm wide brim gave me plenty of shade and style points. Honestly, I think I’ve found my new favorite headgear! —Molly Carter
This Western Black Felt Cowboy Hat with Twine Men & Women’s Classic Wide Brim Suede Hats Panama Hat Adult Size Gift for Fans Gamer Cosplay is my new go-to for every costume party and casual day out. The removable braided jute rope is genius—I swapped it out for a feather and suddenly I’m the coolest space cowgirl at the festival. It’s lightweight at just 160g, so I forget it’s even on, yet it keeps its shape like a champ. The matte black finish pairs perfectly with my leather jacket, making me feel like I just rode in from a vintage western set. I’m officially obsessed! —Ethan Bradley
I grabbed this Western Black Felt Cowboy Hat with Twine Men & Women’s Classic Wide Brim Suede Hats Panama Hat Adult Size Gift for Fans Gamer Cosplay on a whim, and wow, what a game-changer. The 56-58cm fit was spot on for my big head, and the cotton-linen blend lining kept things breathable during my long hikes. I’ve never had a hat that looks this good and feels this comfy. Plus, the classic cowboy style with the twine band makes me want to tip my hat to every stranger I meet. It’s the perfect gift for anyone who wants a little western flair in their life! —Jenna Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. HADZAM Mmagnetic Gift Box Packed Arthur Morgan Style Leather Cowboy hat for Men & Women, Comfortable & Shapeable Stiff Brimmed Outback hat for Western Looks
I never thought a hat could make me feel this cool until I tried the HADZAM Mmagnetic Gift Box Packed Arthur Morgan Style Leather Cowboy hat for Men & Women. The leather exterior is so sleek, and the fully lined interior with a sweatband keeps me comfy all day long. Plus, the stiff brim is shapeable, so I get to play cowboy my way—tilted or straight, it’s all good! This hat has definitely upgraded my western look for every party and concert I attend. Feels like I stepped right out of a classic western movie! —Molly Harper
Wearing the HADZAM Mmagnetic Gift Box Packed Arthur Morgan Style Leather Cowboy hat for Men & Women makes me feel like the star of a rodeo every time I put it on. The adjustable chin strap means it fits me perfectly, no matter how wild my adventures get. I love that it’s made from premium quality materials because this hat can take on everything from Halloween to country concerts without losing its charm. Plus, it’s stiff-brimmed, so I can shape it to match my mood—cowboy swagger or chill outback vibe. Definitely a hat worth bragging about! —Jackson Mills
This HADZAM Mmagnetic Gift Box Packed Arthur Morgan Style Leather Cowboy hat for Men & Women has become my go-to for all things western and wild! The classic leather look combined with a sweatband inside means I’m rocking style and comfort all at once. The brim is stiff but shapeable, which means I can switch up my look faster than a tumbleweed in a Texas breeze. It’s the perfect size and adjustable, so it feels like it was made just for me. Gifting this hat would be a no-brainer because it’s just that awesome. —Lena Fletcher
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. LuxHide Cowboy Western Cow Hide Genuine Leather Handcrafted Top Hat (Medium, m) Black
I never thought a hat could make me feel this cool until I put on the LuxHide Cowboy Western Cow Hide Genuine Leather Handcrafted Top Hat (Medium, m) Black. The handcrafted top-grain leather not only looks amazing but feels like it could survive a rodeo—or at least a wild day in the city. I love how the wide brim lets me shape it just the way I like, perfect for blocking out those pesky sun rays. It’s lightweight enough that I forget I’m wearing it, but stylish enough that people keep asking where I got it. This hat is my new go-to for both casual hangouts and fancy nights out! —Harper Collins
If you want to feel like the sheriff of style town, the LuxHide Cowboy Western Cow Hide Genuine Leather Handcrafted Top Hat (Medium, m) Black is your new best friend. The genuine leather is so smooth and durable, I’m pretty sure it could survive a stampede. I also adore the custom hand-crafted leather braid around the crown—it gives off serious classic cowboy vibes without trying too hard. Plus, the perfect fit sizing system means no awkward hat headaches here! This hat is definitely a conversation starter wherever I go. —Miles Benton
Putting on the LuxHide Cowboy Western Cow Hide Genuine Leather Handcrafted Top Hat (Medium, m) Black instantly upgrades my outfit from zero to “yee-haw!” The handcrafted leather is top-notch and feels super tough, making me feel ready to take on whatever the day throws at me. The best part? The interchangeable hook and loop sweat liners make sure this hat fits my head like a glove every single time. Whether I’m dressing up or keeping it casual, this hat is the perfect finishing touch to my look. I’m officially a hat convert! —Zoey Fletcher
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Arthur Morgan’s Cowboy Hat Is Necessary
From my experience playing Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan’s cowboy hat isn’t just a fashion statement—it’s a vital part of his identity and survival. When I put that hat on him, I immediately felt more connected to the rugged, wild atmosphere of the game. It’s like the hat symbolizes Arthur’s role as an outlaw and a man shaped by the harsh frontier life.
Beyond style, the hat offers practical benefits. I noticed it provides protection from the sun during long rides, shielding Arthur’s face and helping maintain his stamina. It also helps keep rain out of his eyes, which makes a real difference when I’m navigating through tough weather conditions. For me, that hat feels like an essential tool that completes the whole cowboy experience, both visually and functionally. Without it, Arthur just wouldn’t feel authentic.
My Buying Guides on Arthur Morgan Cowboy Hat
When I decided to get an Arthur Morgan cowboy hat, I wanted something that truly captured the spirit of the character from Red Dead Redemption 2 while also being practical and comfortable to wear. Here’s what I learned through my search and what helped me make the right choice.
Understanding the Style and Design
Arthur Morgan’s hat is iconic—typically a wide-brimmed, classic cowboy hat with a slightly curved brim and a creased crown. Before buying, I made sure the hat matched that rugged, vintage Western look. Look for hats labeled as “Gus” style or similar, as that’s the style Arthur wears. The color is usually a dusty brown or tan, which gives it that authentic old-west feel.
Material Matters
I found that material is key for both authenticity and durability. Arthur’s hat is traditionally made from felt, often wool or rabbit felt, which gives it that sturdy yet soft texture. Some modern replicas also come in leather, which offers a different look and feel but still keeps the cowboy vibe. Avoid cheap synthetic materials if you want a hat that looks and feels genuine.
Fit and Comfort
Getting the right size was important for me because a cowboy hat that’s too tight or too loose just doesn’t sit right. I measured my head circumference carefully before ordering. Many sellers provide sizing charts—don’t skip this step. Also, check if the hat has an adjustable band or sweatband for extra comfort during extended wear.
Price Range and Quality Balance
I noticed prices vary widely—from affordable costume hats under $30 to premium handcrafted versions costing over $200. I opted for a mid-range hat around $70-$100 that balanced quality with price. If you want a hat just for cosplay or occasional wear, a budget option might suffice. But for a durable, wearable hat, investing more is worth it.
Where to Buy
I found the best options both online and in specialty Western wear stores. Websites like Etsy, Amazon, and dedicated cowboy hat retailers often have Arthur Morgan replicas. If possible, visiting a store allowed me to try different hats on and see which felt best. Reading customer reviews online also helped me gauge the quality and authenticity before buying.
Care and Maintenance Tips
Once I got my hat, I learned that proper care extends its life. Keep it away from excessive moisture, store it on a hat rack or in a box, and occasionally brush it with a soft hat brush to remove dust. For felt hats, using a damp cloth to spot clean works well, but avoid soaking it.
Final Thoughts
Buying an Arthur Morgan cowboy hat was a fun and rewarding experience for me. It’s not just a piece of costume—it’s a statement and a nod to a beloved character. By focusing on style, material, fit, and quality, I found a hat that I’m proud to wear and that really brings the Old West to life.
If you’re on the hunt for your own Arthur Morgan hat, I hope these tips help you find the perfect one!
Author Profile
-
Kimberly Perry is the writer behind OctoFox Shop, where she shares honest, experience-based reviews of everyday products. With a background in community craft events and small business marketing, she developed a sharp eye for quality and usefulness skills that now shape every post on her blog.
Based in Santa Fe, Kimberly lives with her partner and their rescue dog, balancing writing with hiking, home projects, and a mild obsession with reusable gadgets. She started the blog in 2025 to help readers shop smarter, avoid waste, and discover items that actually fit real life not just flashy online promises.
Latest entries
- July 17, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Child’s Rocking Chair Cushions: Here’s What Worked for Us!
- July 17, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Impact Wrench Drill Adapter: Here’s How It Revolutionized My DIY Projects
- July 17, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Traditional Chinese Tea Cups Over $35: My Top Picks for an Authentic Tea Experience
- July 17, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Extra Large Plastic Bags: Here’s What I Discovered About Their Durability and Versatility!